So I did not feel that there was anywhere I could go to feel accepted. Either I could join integrated groups and become raceless or black groups that would force me to be pro-black/anti-white. The feeling that I had nowhere to go forced me to try to create my own safe space. That is what led me to create this website Black Leadership Analysis.
I wanted to evaluate the thoughts of black people using Spiral Dynamics. I often would read blogs and articles on Spiral Dynamics that mention black people. Most of the time black people were classified as Red/Blue and whites were classified as Orange/Green. Of course, all statements would be qualified by there are black and white people in all memes, but ultimately black people were discussed as at a lower state of development. The dynamic of blacks being in a less complex state was also very prevalent in The Crucible.
The idea that black people are at a lower level of development has been prevalent in science from the very beginning. Dr. Cross explained the origins of this idea in psychology. Now I do not think the founders of Spiral Dynamics intentionally continued the tradition. However, I think science’s inability to confront its racist history has allowed the idea of black inferiority to exist.
Now I do not believe that it is impossible for black people or white people to be generally at different levels of development. However, to make the assertion one must look deeply into Black America. Not just a few hundred test subjects. The great thinkers have to be evaluated. It is possible that higher order thinking appears in a different manner. Once one explores the possibility that the intersection of ethnicity and ego development makes the memes appear differently, one can then assess if black people are generally at a lower level of development.
One of many barriers in Spiral Dynamics is the idea that anyone that talks about ethnicity is Red Meme. It is believed that once a person moves up the Spiral they naturally let go of ethnicity. The goal will be creating a raceless intellectual. If this is the final goal, the Spiral Dynamic community should expect limited influence.
I also felt Spiral Dynamics could be beneficial to the Black community. Often it is difficult for us to have political or philosophical dialogue without immediately moving to ad hominem attacks such as: “you’re brainwashed” you’re a hotep”, “you hate yourself.” The lack of dialogue prevents black people from developing an informed social philosophy to help us navigate an often hostile world.
Now there is quality political discussion within the Black academia. However, there needs to be a method to bring these strategies to the mass of people. If normal people don’t have a way to dialogue, there will be unnecessary division and stagnation. For a group of people already disadvantaged, not being able to dialogue will be detrimental.
I began with the website by randomly picking leaders. The first one I did was Brother Polight. I found him to be pretty impressive from the few YouTube videos I watched. I watched all the videos on his YouTube channel looking for common themes. Once the common themes were determined. I would judge what meme is central to the person’s thinking.
Facebook is the best place to share these articles. However, I realized every Facebook group on Spiral Dynamics was not down to talk about race. So I created my own group Black Leadership Analysis. I wanted it to have it be a place were Integralist and Black people can talk about race. The focus would be on black thinkers. I went through and recruited people I felt to be influential in Spiral Dynamics. It was disheartening to find so few black people in the Integral Facebook Groups. However, all the black people I saw got a personal invitation.
So my Facebook Group has always allowed all ethnicities to be part of the discussion. However, the discussion focuses on black issues and the thoughts of black leaders. Many black members have criticized discussing black issues in front of whites. They mainly think we should “air dirty laundry” to outsiders. My rebuttal is black issues are always in the public sphere. It is better to provide outsiders the opportunity to hear black people to discuss issues candidly to give them perspective.
I also had one person that was white that believed race discussion could only be Red Meme. He was also a big Sam Harris fan. He took one of my posts down in an Integral FB group. So I decided to recruit him for Black Leadership Analysis. I thought it would be good to have someone against the idea in the group to see how my ideas would play in front of the most conservative Integralist.
So the white guy from the other Facebook Group, let’s call him Bill, claims not to see race. However, the first post that he tries to post is of Sam Harris blaming police brutality of black people’s gangster culture. The idea of the video was that Black people idolize gangsters and criminality. Exalting criminals leads to violence and more interactions with the police. Increased police interactions then lead to instances were police use brutal force. I found this an odd video for a person that does not see race to post. I allowed the post because I wanted to critique the video.
My rebuttal along with most people in the group was black people can’t be simplified into a monolith. Also, white people control the “culture” that he has easy access to through television and radio. Ultimately, only a person that has deep-seated anti-black beliefs would even find the video valid. Bill did not change his position, but he understood our perspective. Ultimately, it was a constructive conversation.
Bill symbolized to me the problem with merely dismissing those that speak on race and asserting that black people are at a lower stage of development compared to white people. Because one is living in a culture that dismisses outsiders as savage one will be predisposed to anti-black views. The only way to re-evaluate these views is to study the other sub-culture thoroughly. Until a sub-culture is carefully examined, one can not make any declarations. The study should go beyond test subjects and include the great thinkers.
Ultimately, I want to build a genuinely multi-cultural Integral community. I understand it will take more than one blog to accomplish this. However, I think the discussions we have will help to improve the Integral and the Black community. The world is at a turning point right now, and if the proper dialogue is not established the world could turn to fascism.
November 27, 2018 at 10:43 pm
In truth, given the circumstances, I should probably feel privileged that it was even possible “as a white woman” to even read your view. I am an integrationist. I am morally and politically opposed to the oppression/s of any subgroup of a culture other than “oppression of criminals/criminal activities” which is a complicated discussion.
Evidently, you have read some Ken Wilber, as have I.
Anecdotally: recently I volunteered at a Girls Expo and was somewhat surprised when I found that a short, dark brown (“black”) woman well dressed with straightened hair was the actual Mastermind behind organizing the local form of the event. I noticed that I had no real objection about the difference and felt it was fortunate to meet some impressive lady ….vis a vis: any member of certain groups is always led towards having a better opinion of some other group when s/he gets to meet someone subjectively experienced as impressive, respectable etc..
During my life I have made some meaningful but rather small decisions to support “racial integration” “interracial harmony” in our society. …Just stuff like making sure my own child grew up, like myself, attending interracial schools…and trying to avoid blatant “white only” types of circumstances…interracial neighborhoods….Understandably I don’t want to live surrounded by “colored folk who hate white people” any more than I expect anyone “of color” would feel relaxed in a neighborhood where they felt that the neighbors all hated them…One of these small, but meaningful decisions is that both of my novels do actually have characters of more than one “race” in them on both the sides of “good and evil”.
Just as I still find it culturally insane that women’s rights and work opportunities etc. is not a resolved issue already for a century or more now….I am pleased by the signs of progress but admit how weird it is that 60 years of social progress has enabled us to use the same drinking fountains and that we may have seen each other at work or at school and your children can finally have a toy doll with a skin color the same as your child’s. I mean, I am glad for the progress but that’s just totally crazy that there has had to be these massive civil rights movements just to get that.
That was a lot. I won’t say more right now. Thanks for allowing me to comment.
November 28, 2018 at 12:04 am
You should know this is one blog in a series of five. Go to Personal Blog Entries to see the entire series. Also, look at Leader Analysis section under Dr. Bill Cross. He made an ego development theory for black people. I feel it is important for whites to understand their identity. I would love for whites to creat their own version of Nigrescence.
December 15, 2018 at 2:46 am
I?m amazed, I have to admit. Rarely do I come across a blog that?s both educative and engaging,
and without a doubt, you have hit the nail on the head. The issue is something too few folks are speaking
intelligently about. Now i’m very happy that I found this
in my search for something relating to this. https://vitohubbs2302.webgarden.at/blog/turmeric-curcumin-compared-to