Dr. Umar Johnson is a black scholar that speaks for the two parent household family model. He bases his theories in psychological defects caused by the absence of the father. One of his frequently used theories is that black people that do not have a father in the house will search for their father’s love elsewhere. In women, this will lead to promiscuity. In men, it will result in homosexuality. He also says that the black church derives its power from black women looking for a surrogate husband. In Johnson’s philosophy issues in the black community stem from promiscuity and a breakdown of traditional families.
There are many problems with his philosophy that I have heard repeated by numerous people in the black community. Johnson’s philosophies divided and ultimately weaken the black community. One, it excludes gay people that could be helpful in the overall movement. Two, it leads black people that are in traditional families shaming black people that are not in traditional families. Third, encourages hypermasculinity that is not conducive to today’s society.
DSM removed Homosexuality in 1973. Dr. Johnson as a psychologist should not still be treating homosexuality as a disease. Homosexuality, according to Johnson, is a problem in the black community and is a result and leading to single family households. He acts as if the goal of the black community should be procreation. Many people of all races decide not to have families. Many people of all races have gay people in them. If we as a community continue to promote homophobia we are only going to ostracize numerous black people and we will ostracize ourselves from the rest of the country.
Dr. Johnson does not hold his views on homosexuality due to psychiatric research. His views are solely based cultural biases. The idea that absence of the father causes homosexuality can be easily tested. Dr.Johnson presents no polls conducted by himself or others showing a statistics on homosexuality and single parent households.
In America in 2016, people are beginning to experiment with various types of relationships. Women and men are in open relationships or having non-traditional families. The shaming of these people only weakens the community. As the amount of people in traditional relationships decreases the “strong family” model will be less and less viable as a basis of black liberation.
All the women that are in non-traditional relationships are not there because they could not find a man. Dr. Umar Johnson does not make any concessions for a woman that is a single parent or just single due to a conscious decision. Everyone is not looking for the same type of relationship anymore. People evaluate all types of relationships and which ones best fit her personality. A woman can logically decide that she wants many lovers throughout her life.
It would be difficult to prove scientifically that a single parent household causes psychological damage. Other factors such as income, mental health of the parent, neighborhood, etc. would need to be controlled. Also, each case must be analyzed to see what options the mother has available to her. If he father is emotionally under developed, then a single parent situation could be better. All these issues need to be addressed and accounted for in Dr. Johnson’s methodologies.
Dr. Umar Johnson calls for black men to step up and control the household. He wants the “old school” model of the family. The “old school” model calls for a man to be dominant and a woman to be passive. Much of Dr. Johnson’s rhetoric sounds like advice from the 1950’s. These old models of relationships were discarded long ago. Attempting to artificially force them on people that know relationships are far more complex than this will not work. If anything it will lead to a form of hyper-masculinity that is juvenile and sexist.
This juvenile form of masculinity was on full display with Dr. Boyce Watkins challenged Dr. Umar Johnson credentials. Also, a person on Dr. Watkin’s youtube challenged Dr. Johnson on his plans to create a school. Dr. Watkins who has a Ph.D. from the University of Kentucky asked Dr. Johnson where he received his doctorate from and if he could get a copy of his thesis. The social media battle is well documented and can be googled if the reader has not already heard about it. It ultimately resulted in Dr. Johnson making a ton of negative memes on Dr. Watkins.
July 17, 2017 at 9:12 pm
It’s really simple. Blacks need traditional black families for community growth and development, that my friend is common sense. Look at the successful white, Asian, Arab or East Indian families, most of them have solid traditional families. This allows them to build generational wealth and core family traditions.
You cannot build a successful village by fighting against the laws of nature that God Himself established. Now you’re fighting against God and common sense. As far as the thought that the absence of gay pride or the disagreement with the gay lifestyle for community growth means a masculine male dominated household, well that’s just misleading. We all know that balance is needed to be successful at everything in life. Balancing the women’s views with the man’s veiws is how you create a productive and loving household. This is the family image that needs to be passed down in the black community. Traditional, Balanced, Black Love
July 17, 2017 at 9:59 pm
If Dr. Johnson believes in the black family so much why is he not married? Have you ever wondered about that. I simply believe that people should allow everyone to have the type of relationships they want to have. Ultimately, people will love whom them want or remain single. I think the community must grow to accept all lifestyles.
September 2, 2017 at 11:24 pm
While economically stable and loving marriages are a plus to communities, not everyone wants or even needs to be married. There are plenty of happy, productive, and law-abiding black men and women who are not married either due to circumstances or independent choice. Johnson’s views on women are problematic because they are outdated and do not take into account that there’s no such thing as progress that’s obtained by turning the clock back. As for his views on homosexuality, they are damaging and alienating sentiments that would deprive black communities of significant allies. The thing is that Umar Johnson is not saying anything new and while the fight for racial justice remains important, it’s equally important to have evolved from what leaders in the 1960’s and before did.
LikeLiked by 1 person
September 2, 2017 at 11:42 pm
Thank you. This is my first positive comment on this article.